Criminal Law
5,920 judgments — showing 1601-1700
📚 Read the Criminal Law Study Guide — a topic overview grounded in real cases from this database.
📝 Case Highlights on this topic
Pakistan Limitation Act, 1908FIA shall act in accordance with provisions of FIA Act and Rules of 2002Consistency of PWs during Cross ExaminationSee all Case Highlights →32/2016 Criminal Appeal Muhammad Nawaz and others (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
32/2016 Criminal Appeal Muhammad Nawaz and others (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
1109/2013 Cr.Bail ALI BUX QADRI S/O NATHU KHAN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1109/2013 Cr.Bail ALI BUX QADRI S/O NATHU KHAN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
354/2010 Cr.Appeal Heman and another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
354/2010 Cr.Appeal Heman and another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
510/2023 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD ABID S/O MUHAMMAD AFZAL (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
510/2023 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD ABID S/O MUHAMMAD AFZAL (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
43/2013 Cr.Appeal Jabbar Gopang (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
43/2013 Cr.Appeal Jabbar Gopang (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
12/2012 Conf.Case The State (Applicant) V/S Rashid Aslam & Arshad Nabi (Respondent)
12/2012 Conf.Case The State (Applicant) V/S Rashid Aslam & Arshad Nabi (Respondent)…
308/2021 Suit M/S. FOREL INTERNATIONAL TRADING & OTHERS (Plaintiff) V/S WAQAS AHMED JAT & OTHERS (Defendant)
Suit barred for staying freezing order passed under section 5(5) of the FIA Act, 1974.…
421/2020 Cr.Bail SALEEM KHALID S/O KHALID ABDUL AZIZ (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
421/2020 Cr.Bail SALEEM KHALID S/O KHALID ABDUL AZIZ (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
519/2019 Cr.Bail Ali Sher (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
519/2019 Cr.Bail Ali Sher (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
1574/2020 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD FAISAL @ CHITTA (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1574/2020 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD FAISAL @ CHITTA (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
87/2024 Criminal Appeal Ghulam Mustafa @ Lanti Jakhrani (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Section 311 P.P.C. Honour Killing Conviction.…
766/2018 Cr.Misc. Khalid Hussain & others (Applicant) V/S Asif Iqbal & Others (Respondent)
766/2018 Cr.Misc. Khalid Hussain & others (Applicant) V/S Asif Iqbal & Others (Respondent)…
101/2009 Cr.Appeal Khadim Khoso & another (Appellant) V/S The state (Respondent)
101/2009 Cr.Appeal Khadim Khoso & another (Appellant) V/S The state (Respondent)…
89/2023 Cr.Rev ARY Communication Limited & ors (Applicant) V/S INDEPENDENCE Newspapers Corporation Pvt Ltd & ors (Respondent)
89/2023 Cr.Rev ARY Communication Limited & ors (Applicant) V/S INDEPENDENCE Newspapers Corporation Pvt Ltd & ors (Respondent)…
315/2010 Cr.Appeal Adil Sher (Appellant) V/S The state (Respondent)
315/2010 Cr.Appeal Adil Sher (Appellant) V/S The state (Respondent)…
261/2018 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. SIKANDAR ALI LASHARI S/O ALI MUHAMMAD (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
Decision/Judgment in the appeals filed by Sikandar Ali Lashari (District Judge) against the conviction of death penalty decided by A.T.C. on the charge of murder of Aqib Hussain son of District & Sessions Judge.…
98/2001 Cr.Rev Roshan Ali Dero S/o Ghulam Haider Dero (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
98/2001 Cr.Rev Roshan Ali Dero S/o Ghulam Haider Dero (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
628/2024 Cr.Bail SANIYAL ALI S/O MUHAMMAD ALI (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
Coming to the proposition bail in an offense punishable up to seven years, broadly speaking a person accused of a bailable offense has a right of admission to bail and an arrested person can be refused bail if it appears…
304/2016 Cr.Appeal JAHANZEB S/O MUHAMMAD ASLAM (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
304/2016 Cr.Appeal JAHANZEB S/O MUHAMMAD ASLAM (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
968/2024 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD YAMEEN S/O MUHAMMAD AMIN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
The question involved in the present proceedings is whether the alleged amount could be recovered by detaining the applicant for an indefinite period. Section 489-F, P.P.C. was originally inserted in Pakistan Penal Code,…
263/2021 Criminal Miscelleneous ABDUL GHAFFAR S/O MUHAMMAD SHARIF (Applicant) V/S THE STATE & ANOTHER (Respondent)
263/2021 Criminal Miscelleneous ABDUL GHAFFAR S/O MUHAMMAD SHARIF (Applicant) V/S THE STATE & ANOTHER (Respondent)…
85/2021 Criminal Miscelleneous MST. ROZEENA RAZZAQ D/O ABDUL RAZZAQ (Applicant) V/S MIRZA MOHSIN ALI JAH & OTHERS (Respondent)
85/2021 Criminal Miscelleneous MST. ROZEENA RAZZAQ D/O ABDUL RAZZAQ (Applicant) V/S MIRZA MOHSIN ALI JAH & OTHERS (Respondent)…
1010/2020 Cr.Bail HASSAN RABBANI S/O TARIQ RABBANI (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1010/2020 Cr.Bail HASSAN RABBANI S/O TARIQ RABBANI (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
34/2005 Cr.Appeal Muhammad Pali (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
34/2005 Cr.Appeal Muhammad Pali (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
164/2024 Cr.Bail Zeeshan (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
The law on bail is now well settled. In cases where the offense falls outside the non-prohibitory clause of section 497(1) of Cr.P.C., bail is to be granted as a matter of course, and rejection of the same is an exceptio…
100/2013 Cr.J.A Abdul Aziz Bhatti (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
100/2013 Cr.J.A Abdul Aziz Bhatti (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
178/2017 Criminal Appeal BILAWAL S/O RAMZAN & ANOTHER (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
178/2017 Criminal Appeal BILAWAL S/O RAMZAN & ANOTHER (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
19/2013 Spl.Cr.A.T.A. Nawab Siraj Ali S/o Imdad Ali Talpur (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Judgment in murder case of Shahzaib…
29/2021 Cr.Rev MS.RUBINA MIR D/O LATE MIR MUHAMMAD (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
29/2021 Cr.Rev MS.RUBINA MIR D/O LATE MIR MUHAMMAD (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
210/2017 Cr.Misc. muhammad anwar qureshi (Applicant) V/S muhammad ayoob & others (Respondent)
210/2017 Cr.Misc. muhammad anwar qureshi (Applicant) V/S muhammad ayoob & others (Respondent)…
182/2009 Cr.Misc. Khuda Bux (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
182/2009 Cr.Misc. Khuda Bux (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
89/2009 Cr.J.A Abdul Hayee (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
89/2009 Cr.J.A Abdul Hayee (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
1533/2013 Cr.Bail ABDUL KABEER KAZI S/O MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1533/2013 Cr.Bail ABDUL KABEER KAZI S/O MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
47/2015 Spl.Cr.A.T.A. Amjad Ali (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
47/2015 Spl.Cr.A.T.A. Amjad Ali (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
622/2024 Cr.Misc. Mst Muskan & Another (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
622/2024 Cr.Misc. Mst Muskan & Another (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
491/2011 Cr.Appeal Abdul Ghaffar (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
491/2011 Cr.Appeal Abdul Ghaffar (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
646/2024 Cr.Bail TALHA SAMOO S/O GHULAM NABI (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
In such circumstances, when the offenses do not fall within the prohibition contained in Section 497(1) Cr. P.C and punishment of the offense is less than 10 years, the Supreme Court in the case of Iftikhar Ahmed v The …
38/2020 Cr.Rev Pir Bux Brohi & another (Applicant) V/S The State & another (Respondent)
Against Order of Trial Court…
13/2009 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. Waseem Ahmed and another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
13/2009 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. Waseem Ahmed and another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
2/2018 Cr.J.A Bilawal Dasti (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
2/2018 Cr.J.A Bilawal Dasti (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
108/2007 Cr.Rev Ali Raza (Applicant) V/S Haji Mir Muhammad and others (Respondent)
108/2007 Cr.Rev Ali Raza (Applicant) V/S Haji Mir Muhammad and others (Respondent)…
480/2025 Criminal Miscelleneous FAIZAN BASIQ S/O AGHA NAIER HUSSAIN (Applicant) V/S NOORUL ARFEEN QURESHI & ANOTHER (Respondent)
480/2025 Criminal Miscelleneous FAIZAN BASIQ S/O AGHA NAIER HUSSAIN (Applicant) V/S NOORUL ARFEEN QURESHI & ANOTHER (Respondent)…
2324/2023 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD TANVEER KHAN S/O MUHAMMAD YOUSUF KHAN (Applicant) V/S XTH ADJ KHI SOUTH & ANOTHER (Respondent)
The only question involved in the present bail matter is whether the bail can be refused in section 471 PPC., which is a bailable offense, whereas Sections 406 & 468 are punishable by up to seven years. In such circumsta…
52/2011 Cr.Rev Abdul Hameed (Applicant) V/S P.O Sindh (Respondent)
52/2011 Cr.Rev Abdul Hameed (Applicant) V/S P.O Sindh (Respondent)…
34/2020 Criminal Appeal Zubair Jakhrani (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
34/2020 Criminal Appeal Zubair Jakhrani (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
159/2020 Cr.Rev SYED ALI ZAIDI & ORS (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
159/2020 Cr.Rev SYED ALI ZAIDI & ORS (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
15/2013 Cr.Acq.A. Mukhtiar Ahmed Siyal (Appellant) V/S Piyaro Siyal & others (Respondent)
15/2013 Cr.Acq.A. Mukhtiar Ahmed Siyal (Appellant) V/S Piyaro Siyal & others (Respondent)…
1622/2023 Cr.Bail SHABBIR MUHAMMAD S/O MUHAMMAD BAQAR (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1622/2023 Cr.Bail SHABBIR MUHAMMAD S/O MUHAMMAD BAQAR (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
154/2012 Cr.Appeal Noman & another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
154/2012 Cr.Appeal Noman & another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
162/2019 Criminal Appeal SHAHID WAHAB SIDDIQUI S/O ABDUL WAHAB (Appellant) V/S SYED FARHAJ AHMED & OTHERS (Respondent)
162/2019 Criminal Appeal SHAHID WAHAB SIDDIQUI S/O ABDUL WAHAB (Appellant) V/S SYED FARHAJ AHMED & OTHERS (Respondent)…
32/2021 Conf.Case Muhammad Kashif (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
32/2021 Conf.Case Muhammad Kashif (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
358/2025 Cr.Bail AZHAR ALI S/O ABDUL RASHEED (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
358/2025 Cr.Bail AZHAR ALI S/O ABDUL RASHEED (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
99/2015 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. NADEEM NASIR S/O NASIR MEHMOOD (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
99/2015 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. NADEEM NASIR S/O NASIR MEHMOOD (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
14/2018 Cr.Rev Khalid Mehmood (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
14/2018 Cr.Rev Khalid Mehmood (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
111/2013 Cr.Misc. Mst.Saeeda Shaikh (Applicant) V/S The SSP Larkana and others (Respondent)
111/2013 Cr.Misc. Mst.Saeeda Shaikh (Applicant) V/S The SSP Larkana and others (Respondent)…
578/2025 Const. P. Fahad Junaid s/o Junaid Jalal (Petitioner) V/S Province of Sindh & Others (Respondent)
police cannot be bound to record FIR after obtaining permission from the Court…
85/2019 Cr.J.A Ahsan Marfani (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Against Order of Trial Court(Narcotics Above 7 Years)…
152/2019 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. SYED MEHROZ MEHDI ZAIDI S/O SYED HASSAN MUHAMMAD (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
152/2019 Spl.Anti.Ter.A. SYED MEHROZ MEHDI ZAIDI S/O SYED HASSAN MUHAMMAD (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
79/2011 Cr.Tran Bakshoo (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
79/2011 Cr.Tran Bakshoo (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
357/2025 Cr.Bail Muhammad Yousif (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
357/2025 Cr.Bail Muhammad Yousif (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
30/2011 Cr.Rev Feroz Khan Baloch (Applicant) V/S First Women Bank & Ors (Respondent)
30/2011 Cr.Rev Feroz Khan Baloch (Applicant) V/S First Women Bank & Ors (Respondent)…
205/2013 Cr.Bail Abdul Sattar Jalbani and another (Applicant) V/S The state (Respondent)
205/2013 Cr.Bail Abdul Sattar Jalbani and another (Applicant) V/S The state (Respondent)…
180/2019 Cr.Bail Waheed Dehpal Chandio (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
180/2019 Cr.Bail Waheed Dehpal Chandio (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
44/2024 Criminal Appeal Shafi Muhammad Sarki (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Use of modern devices in the investigation of Narcotics Cases.…
510/2020 Cr.Bail Syed Zaman Ali Shah (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
510/2020 Cr.Bail Syed Zaman Ali Shah (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
47/2021 Cr.Bail Muhammad Siddique & others (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
47/2021 Cr.Bail Muhammad Siddique & others (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
869/2019 Cr.J.A KHALID AHMED S/O ABDUL REHMAN (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
Father killed his daughter on the suspicion of being unchaste. No mitigating circumstance in favour of appellant was found for awarding lesser punishment. Death sentence confirmed…
124/2021 Cr.Bail Talib Hussain Chachar (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Post Arrest Bail…
613/2019 Cr.Bail ABDUL MAJEED S/O ALLAH DITTA (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
613/2019 Cr.Bail ABDUL MAJEED S/O ALLAH DITTA (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
571/2009 Cr.Bail Muhammad Hanif S. Kalia and two others (Applicant) V/S State (Respondent)
571/2009 Cr.Bail Muhammad Hanif S. Kalia and two others (Applicant) V/S State (Respondent)…
318/2002 Cr.Misc. Ali Zahir Jafari (Applicant) V/S The State (Appellant)
318/2002 Cr.Misc. Ali Zahir Jafari (Applicant) V/S The State (Appellant)…
272/2013 Cr.J.A Muh (Appellant) V/S Party-2 (Respondent)
272/2013 Cr.J.A Muh (Appellant) V/S Party-2 (Respondent)…
49/2013 Cr.Rev Ahsan Mian (Applicant) V/S The Statte (Respondent)
49/2013 Cr.Rev Ahsan Mian (Applicant) V/S The Statte (Respondent)…
1399/2018 Cr.Bail FAHAD PAREKH S/O MUHAMMAD IQBAL (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
1399/2018 Cr.Bail FAHAD PAREKH S/O MUHAMMAD IQBAL (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
66/2018 Cr.Bail Ameer Khan Awan (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
66/2018 Cr.Bail Ameer Khan Awan (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
145/2009 Cr.Rev Mrs. Ghazala Parveen (Applicant) V/S Sadiq Daniel & 18 others (Respondent)
145/2009 Cr.Rev Mrs. Ghazala Parveen (Applicant) V/S Sadiq Daniel & 18 others (Respondent)…
1463/2016 Cr.Bail Siraj Muhammad (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
1463/2016 Cr.Bail Siraj Muhammad (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
2271/2021 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD TAHIR S/O GHULAM QADIR (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
post-arrest bail in FIR No.451/2021 for offences punishable under sections 269, 270 PPC & 8(i) of Sindh Prohibition of Preparation, Manufacturing, Storage, Sale & Use of Gutka and Manpuri, Act 2019…
1965/2021 Cr.Bail MUHAMMAD UMER S/O SAINDAN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
In view of the above, the applicant / accused Muhammad Umar son of Saindan is admitted to post-arrest bail subject to his furnishing solvent surety in the sum of Rs.100,000.00 (Rupees one hundred thousand only) and a P.R…
174/2020 Cr.Bail SAMIULLAH S/O MAHBOOB (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
174/2020 Cr.Bail SAMIULLAH S/O MAHBOOB (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
68/2014 Cr.Acq.A. Zulfiqar Ali Baloch (Appellant) V/S Parkash & others (Respondent)
68/2014 Cr.Acq.A. Zulfiqar Ali Baloch (Appellant) V/S Parkash & others (Respondent)…
3/2019 Criminal Appeal Dost Muhammad Thebo & Another (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Against Order of Trial Court(Narcotics Life)…
460/2018 Criminal Appeal THE STATE / ANF (Appellant) V/S NADEEM BAHADUR (Respondent)
Her reference to Article 157 of the Limitation Act is erroneous as the appellant has not filed an appeal against an order of acquittal. This Revision Application is against conviction in which, according to the appellant…
202/2017 Cr.Rev N. J. AUTOS (Applicant) V/S THE STATE & 02 OTHERS (Respondent)
202/2017 Cr.Rev N. J. AUTOS (Applicant) V/S THE STATE & 02 OTHERS (Respondent)…
29/2020 Criminal Appeal Parvez Khan (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
29/2020 Criminal Appeal Parvez Khan (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
1000/2020 Cr.Bail Nabi Bux (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
1000/2020 Cr.Bail Nabi Bux (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
1449/2008 Cr.Bail AIJAZUL HAQ (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
1449/2008 Cr.Bail AIJAZUL HAQ (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
194/2010 Cr.Bail Muhammad Shoaib (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
194/2010 Cr.Bail Muhammad Shoaib (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
2/2017 Cr.Rev Party-1 (Applicant) V/S Party-2 (Respondent)
2/2017 Cr.Rev Party-1 (Applicant) V/S Party-2 (Respondent)…
461/2011 Cr.Bail Rashid (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
461/2011 Cr.Bail Rashid (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
201/2017 Criminal Appeal Muhammad Yaseen (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
201/2017 Criminal Appeal Muhammad Yaseen (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
379/2024 Cr.Bail Muhammad Bilal (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
379/2024 Cr.Bail Muhammad Bilal (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
589/2011 Cr.Bail Badshah alias Muhammad Saleh (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)
589/2011 Cr.Bail Badshah alias Muhammad Saleh (Applicant) V/S The State (Respondent)…
486/2018 Criminal Appeal MUHAMMAD KASHIF S/O SHER MUHAMMAD & ANOTHER (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
The test for weighing the evidence of identification proceedings is to first assess the system variables, i.e. the precautions taken at the test identification parade, and then to assess the estimator variables i.e. the …
269/2012 Criminal Appeal Asad Khan (Appellant) V/S The State (Respondent)
Appellant Asad Khan dissatisfied with the judgment passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Karachi whereby the appellant Asad Khan was convicted for committing Qatl-e-Amd of his wife Mst. Aneela an offenc…
797/2019 Cr.Acq.A. Askari Bank Limited (Appellant) V/S Tara Chand S/o Jasso Mal (Respondent)
797/2019 Cr.Acq.A. Askari Bank Limited (Appellant) V/S Tara Chand S/o Jasso Mal (Respondent)…
67/2025 Cr.Bail Shakil Ahmed Shaikh (Applicant) V/S The State (NAB) & Another (Respondent)
67/2025 Cr.Bail Shakil Ahmed Shaikh (Applicant) V/S The State (NAB) & Another (Respondent)…
297/2021 Spl.Cr.Rev. HANIF MOOSA S/O MOOSA & ANOTHER (Applicant) V/S THE STATE & ANOTHER (Respondent)
Intent of section 540 CrPC is to ensure a just decision. If that leads to filling of lacuna in evidence, such consequence does not come in the way of exercising the power.…
95/2020 Cr.Rev GHOUS BUX S/O SUFAR KHAN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
95/2020 Cr.Rev GHOUS BUX S/O SUFAR KHAN (Applicant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…
288/2019 Criminal Appeal MUHAMMAD SALEEM SHAHZAD S/O PARO (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)
288/2019 Criminal Appeal MUHAMMAD SALEEM SHAHZAD S/O PARO (Appellant) V/S THE STATE (Respondent)…