← All Case Highlights

Judgment on Custody of Minor

PLD 2004 Lahore 395 and 2009 MLD 33, which .rulings were distinguish · Lahore High Court

This case was about a custody dispute over a young boy named Bilal Ahmad following his father's death. After the father died, the boy's mother, Mst. Asima, lived with her in-laws but was later forced out of the house, while the paternal grandmother retained custody of the child. The mother went to court multiple times to recover custody, initially under the Criminal Procedure Code and later under the Guardians and Wards Act. Lower courts had ruled against her partly based on the five-year-old child's own statement that he preferred living with his grandmother. However, on appeal, the District Judge reversed this and ordered the child be returned to his mother. The grandmother then challenged that decision before the Lahore High Court.

The High Court dismissed the grandmother's petition and upheld the mother's right to custody. The judge personally interviewed the child and found he had been influenced to say negative things about his mother, which she considered psychologically harmful. The court emphasized that under Islamic law, a mother's right to custody takes precedence over a paternal grandmother's, and that a child's welfare, including emotional and mental wellbeing, must guide custody decisions. The court also noted the mother's sacrifices and continued efforts to regain her son.

This case matters because it reinforces that courts must prioritize a child's overall welfare, including emotional health, and affirms the mother's preferential right to custody under Islamic law.

Read the full judgment →